October 2026

Second Sons Recruiter

Under Scrutiny Part 7: From Charlottesville to Second Sons

Under Scrutiny | Investigation 001 | Part 07 Some people arrive in an organization with very little public history behind them. Shawn Beauvais-MacDonald is not one of those people. He is a man who publically has spewed his hate. His involvement in far-right politics predates Second Sons Canada by nearly a decade, and much of that history played out publicly. He was involved with Quebec nationalist group La Meute, travelled from Quebec to the 2017 Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, later became associated with the Frontenac Active Club, publicly described himself as a Nazi, and has now emerged as …

Under Scrutiny Part 7: From Charlottesville to Second Sons Read Post »

NDA Post

Under Scrutiny Part 6: Behind the Recruitment Pitch

Under Scrutiny | Investigation 001 | Part 06 For the past several installments of this investigation, Second Sons Canada has been examined largely through what it chooses to show the public. The website presents a disciplined, nationalist men’s organization centred on fitness, camaraderie, activism and what it describes as the preservation of Canadian heritage. Its public imagery is carefully controlled. Its members often appear masked. Its language is frequently provocative, but it is also polished enough to remain within the familiar vocabulary of nationalism, self-improvement and political grievance. Recruitment is where that public image is tested. According to a former …

Under Scrutiny Part 6: Behind the Recruitment Pitch Read Post »

Hate Messages

When Skepticism Becomes Cruelty: Megyn Kelly and the Cornell Jane Doe

There is a legitimate conversation to be had about the Cornell Seven case. There are disputed facts. There are questions about consent, intoxication, changing accounts, investigative decisions, due process and how institutions responded. Seven men have been publicly accused of serious conduct, and those allegations have not yet resulted in criminal convictions. Those questions deserve scrutiny. What they do not require is cruelty. And that is where Megyn Kelly crossed a line. In discussing Jane Doe, the woman who alleges she was drugged and sexually assaulted by members of Cornell University’s Chi Phi fraternity, Kelly did not limit herself to …

When Skepticism Becomes Cruelty: Megyn Kelly and the Cornell Jane Doe Read Post »

Under Scrutiny Post 5

Under Scrutiny Part 5: What the Website Tells Us

Under Scrutiny | Investigation 001 | Part 05 There is a temptation, when investigating an organization like Second Sons Canada, to look immediately for what is hidden. Private chats. Internal documents. Anonymous sources. Deleted posts. Information the organization never intended the public to see. But sometimes the most revealing material is already sitting in plain sight. Second Sons Canada has published a remarkable amount about itself on its own website. It explains who it believes belongs, why its members wear masks, what political activism means to the organization, what kind of men it wants to recruit, where it operates, how …

Under Scrutiny Part 5: What the Website Tells Us Read Post »

Under Scrutiny Post 4

Under Scrutiny Part 4: When the Actions Speak Louder

Under Scrutiny | Investigation 001 | Part 04 Second Sons Canada tells the public what it is: a Canadian men’s nationalist organization centred on fitness, camaraderie, activism and mutual support. Its website presents an image of men training together, building friendships and taking responsibility for themselves at a time when, in the organization’s telling, many Canadian men feel politically ignored and culturally displaced. An organization is entitled to describe itself in its own words, and those words are an important part of understanding it. They are not, however, the entire story. Organizations also reveal themselves through the choices they make …

Under Scrutiny Part 4: When the Actions Speak Louder Read Post »

Under Scrutiny Post 3

Under Scrutiny Part 3: Second Sons Canada — The Myth of the Dispossessed

Under Scrutiny | Investigation 001 | Part 03. Second Sons Canada built its name around a historical story: the eldest son inherited, while the second son was forced to go out into the world and make something of himself. It is a compelling story. It is also an incomplete one. Second Sons uses that historical image to describe modern Canadian men who, in the organization’s words, have had their “birthright” stripped away and are being displaced by foreigners. But if we’re going to use history to explain the present, then we should examine the history properly. What actually happened to …

Under Scrutiny Part 3: Second Sons Canada — The Myth of the Dispossessed Read Post »

Blog Post - Motion 25 Denied

The Motion the Internet Put on Trial: What Judge Sullivan Actually Decided

On September 29, 2026, Lindsay Clancy returned to Plymouth Superior Court for the first time since her murder trial ended in a mistrial. Her attorney, Kevin Reddington, renewed a request under Massachusetts Rule of Criminal Procedure 25 asking Judge William Sullivan to enter findings of not guilty rather than permit the case to return to another jury. Two days later, Judge Sullivan denied that request in a five-page written ruling. Online, the decision was quickly compressed into competing headlines: the judge had “rejected the insanity defence,” the judge had “confirmed her guilt,” the defence had suddenly claimed Clancy “didn’t do …

The Motion the Internet Put on Trial: What Judge Sullivan Actually Decided Read Post »

Under Scrutiny Post 2

Under Scrutiny Part 2: Second Sons Canada — Brotherhood, Birthright and Belonging

Under Scrutiny | Investigation 001 | Part 2. What does it mean to belong to a country, and who gets to decide? Second Sons Canada’s website offers prospective members a familiar proposition: friendship, physical fitness, shared traditions and a community of men working toward common goals. But the organization’s message extends well beyond encouraging men to exercise together. Its website introduces ideas about ancestry, inherited national identity and a birthright that it claims is being taken away. Its membership requirements also contain an interesting distinction between Canadian citizens and certain non-citizens who may be considered for membership. Understanding how these …

Under Scrutiny Part 2: Second Sons Canada — Brotherhood, Birthright and Belonging Read Post »

Under Scrutiny Post 1

Under Scrutiny Part 1: Second Sons Canada — Beyond the Masks

Under Scrutiny | Investigation 001 | Part 1. What happens when an organization presents itself as a brotherhood built around fitness, friendship and Canadian identity, while independent researchers identify it as part of a broader white-supremacist movement? That question is at the centre of this investigation. But it is only the beginning. Second Sons Canada describes itself as a Canadian men’s nationalist club established in 2024. Its website emphasizes physical fitness, camaraderie, personal responsibility and mutual support among men who share its values. Those activities, considered individually, are neither unusual nor inherently objectionable. Canadians join fitness clubs, community organizations and …

Under Scrutiny Part 1: Second Sons Canada — Beyond the Masks Read Post »

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top